Following both her father-in-law's death and a divorce, New Yorker Jesse returns to a small town to live with her widowed mother-in-law. She struggles to fit in with the local townsfolk, who don't welcome her with open arms--to say the least. Jesse becomes acquainted with the local pastor, her widowed brother-in-law, falling in love with him, much to the dismay of the community. Things get even more complicated when her ex-husband shows up, suspiciously trying to win her back. Between her love life and her entangled in-laws, Jesse is tested as she seeks the answer to where she truly belongs.