There's an old family legend that if someone receives a kismet cookie and sleeps with it under their pillow, then they will dream of their true love. As a teenager, Sarah (Sarah Ramos) did this. When her dream showed Travis (Carlos Marks) was her true love, she went to him to tell him. Unfortunately, Travis was marrying someone else. Sarah ran away to become a writer. Now she's returned to her hometown, and discovered Travis is the father of the child who won her writing contest.